Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 5/1.
Cookie Jar Cafe
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Now
  • Our Story
  • Reservations
  • Contact
  • Valentine's Day 2021
interior

Desserts

Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Desserts

Tortes

Torte
00000

Torte

Chocolate, Banana, Pumpkin, Cherry, Blueberry, Peppermint, Peanut ButterLarge +$24.95Small +$13.95

00000

Bars & Cookies

Your other favorite cookies available upon request...
Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Oatmeal Raisin, and Coconut

20002

Chess Bars

$1.99

20002
00000

Cornflake Candy

$1.99

00000
00000

Decorated Sugar Cookies

$2.49

00000
00000

Brownies

$1.99

00000
00000

Iced Brownie

$2.49

00000

Strawberry Desserts

Available for the months of April - August

Strawberry Torte
20002

Strawberry Torte

Large +$25.95Small +$14.95

20002
10001

Strawberry Cheesecake

Large +$25.95Small +$14.95

10001
Strawberry Pie
20002

Strawberry Pie

Large +$25.95Small +$14.95

20002

Rolls

10001

Cinnamon Rolls

Pan +$10.49

10001
30003

Dinner Rolls

One Dozen +$4.75

30003

Cupcakes

Pre-order with a 48 hour notice

Wedding
10001

Wedding

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

10001
00000

Chocolate with Sprinkles

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Chocolate with Buttercream

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
Strawberry
00000

Strawberry

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
10001

Fresh Strawberry

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

10001
Apple Spice
00000

Apple Spice

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
10001

Gingerbread

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

10001
00000

Yellow with Chocolate

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Cookies and Cream

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Raspberry

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Snicker Doodle

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
10001

Carrot Cake

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

10001
00000

White with Sprinkles

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
Chocolate on Chocolate
00000

Chocolate on Chocolate

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Lemon

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
Red Velvet
31002

Red Velvet

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

31002
00000

Pumpkin Spice

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Banana with Cinnamon

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Peppermint Patty

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
Birthday Cake
00000

Birthday Cake

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
00000

Blueberry

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

00000
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
10001

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

10001
10001

Orange Creamcicle

4" Small +$1.256" Regular +$2.50

10001

Pies

Cream Pies
40004

Cream Pies

$13.95Coconut - Chocolate - Lemon - Butterscotch

40004
10001

Apple Pie

$14.95

10001
10001

Pumpkin Pie

$13.95

10001
Pecan Pie
10001

Pecan Pie

$14.95

10001

Fruit Turnovers

Available from September - January

00000

Fruit Turnovers

Apple - Peach - Cherry - Blueberry

00000

Cakes

Layered Cakes
20002

Layered Cakes

Italian Cream - German Chocolate - Carrot - Fresh Strawberry3 Layer +$35.992 Layer +$24.991 Layer +$13.95

20002
00000

Bunt Cakes

$24.99Carmel Apple Cake - Banana Pound Cake - Vanilla Pound Cake - Lemon Pound Cake

00000
Layered Cakes
10001

Layered Cakes

Red Velvet - Coconut - Chocolate on Chocolate3 Layer +$32.952 Layer +$22.951 Layer +$12.95

10001

All baked goods are available for Pre-Order with 48 hour notice.

Made with by Popmenu
Cookie Jar Cafe
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window